*
 
Comma Usage


SMARTHINKING Writer's Handbook

Chapter 5, Lesson 9

Comma Usage


 

Objective

In this lesson, you'll learn why commas are necessary in writing and the most common principles of comma usage.

The Necessity of Commas

Commas are signals that help readers understand the meaning writers create when they compose sentences. These signals tell readers, for instance, which words need to be separated from each other or which words are not essential to the basic grammar of a sentence. In short, commas help readers make sense of writing because they provide pieces of information necessary for complete comprehension of a writer's ideas.

An example sentence highlights the necessity of commas:

For Susan Mary was the perfect mentor.

As it stands, this sentence is difficult to understand. Is the writer trying to communicate something about a person named "Susan Mary," and has this writer simply left out some important words? Or, is this writer trying to communicate something about two separate people, "Susan" and "Mary"?

When a comma is added, however, the meaning of this sentence is perfectly clear:

For Susan, Mary was the perfect mentor.

With the added comma, anyone who reads this sentence understands that the writer is talking about two separate people who've had a professional mentoring relationship, whereas without the comma, the meaning of this sentence is ambiguous.

Common Principles of Comma Usage

There are many principles guiding comma usage, and yet there are a few that are used most frequently. Understanding these basic principles and being able to apply them in your own writing will help ensure that readers understand what you're trying to communicate.

(1) Use a comma to separate introductory elements at the beginning of a sentence from the main, independent clause:

Introductory element, main clause.

Words, phrases, or clauses that are placed before the main independent clause of a sentence are known as "introductory elements." Most often, these introductory elements tell when, where, why, or how the action expressed by the predicate occurred. A comma is needed at the end of an introductory element to signal to readers that the introduction has ended and the main independent clause will follow:

In the morning, I like to drink coffee.

On the sunny porch, she placed her most ailing plants.

Because we were thrilled about winning the daily lottery, we jumped up and down.

Like screeching parrots, my friends and I sang at the top of our lungs.

Note: If an introductory element is short and there's no possibility of misreading it, then the comma can be omitted:

Later she went to the store.

However, it is usually best to get in the habit of placing a comma after every introductory element.

Later, she went to the store.

(2) Use commas and a coordinating conjunction to separate three or more items (words, phrases, or clauses) listed in a series:

Main clause item, item, coordinating conjunction item.

Note: See Lesson 5 for an explanation of coordinating conjunctions.

A comma is needed between brief items in a list to signal to readers when one item ends and another one begins:

I tie-dyed my t-shirt various shades of yellow, orange, and red.

They wanted to go downtown, see a movie, and then eat dinner.

My parents hope that I'd go to college, finish my degree, and get a good job.

Note: According to some writing handbooks, the comma before the coordinating conjunction is considered optional. However, this principle of comma usage applies to journalistic writing, such as in newspapers and magazines; in academic writing, the comma should always be included before the coordinating conjunction.

(3) Use a comma to separate coordinate adjectives:

adjective , adjective noun

Coordinate adjectives are two or more descriptive words that provide additional information about a noun or pronoun. If these adjectives are placed next to each other, commas must separate them:

The hot, smoky room absolutely took my breath away.

She was an enthusiastic, energetic moderator.

Although she wanted to go swimming, she settled for splashing around in a pool of murky, oil-spattered water.

(4) Use a pair of commas to separate nonessential elements (phrases and clauses) from the main clause:

Part of main clause, nonessential element, part of main clause.

Phrases and clauses that are not necessary for an independent clause to be considered a complete sentence are known as "nonessential" (or "restrictive") elements. Generally, these nonessential elements provide additional description of nouns and pronouns.

Carol, a registered nurse, supervised the wellness screening.

The horses, freshly brushed, scampered about the riding ring.

I wanted to tell my brother, my confidante for years, what happened.

In these sentences, the phrases enclosed in commas provide additional information about the nouns or pronouns they're describing; and yet, these phrases are not essential for each independent clause to be a grammatically complete sentence. Consequently, the commas are needed to signal the nonessential nature of these phrases.

Sometimes, a particular word can suggest whether a phrase or clause is nonessential or essential. Usually, the word which is used to begin a phrase or clause not essential to understanding the precise meaning of a sentence, while the word that is used with a phrase or clause absolutely essential to understanding the precise meaning of a sentence:

The phone, which had a shrill tone, rang incessantly.
(nonessential phrase introduced by "which," so commas are needed)

The phone that connected her home office to her company's headquarters rang incessantly.
(essential phrase introduced by "that," so no commas are needed)

In the first sentence, the implication is that there is a single phone in the house; therefore, describing its tone isn't an essential part of understanding the exact meaning of the sentence. As a result, the phrase "which had a shrill tone" is enclosed in commas. However, in the second sentence, the implication is that there are multiple phones in the house, and that the only one ringing constantly was the one connecting the home office to the company's building. In this case, the phrase "that connected her home office to her company's headquarters" is essential to understanding the exact meaning of the sentence, and therefore it's not enclosed in commas.

Summary

Commas are signals used to help clarify the meaning of writing. When placed according to common principles of usage, commas can help readers understand a piece of writing. As writers, we need to know how to use commas appropriately to help readers clearly comprehend the message we're communicating.